| |
This week's assignment: "A Tale of
Two Leaders" was the title of the eighth episode of "The Apprentice." With
11 candidates left, Donald Trump's task of the week for the two teams was to
develop a recruitment campaign for the New York City Police Department.
Donny Deutsch of Deutsch Advertising was put in charge of picking the best
campaign. Deutsch instructed the teams to develop a campaign that spoke to
the "heart and emotions" -- addressing what would make recruits want to
serve with New York's finest.
In the boardroom
Mosaic won by a landslide with freshman
quarterback Andy as the project manager. The team's ad campaign focused on
emotions and heart with slogans such as, "When was the last time you saved a
life and made your family proud?"
Apex, under the incredibly weak and
indecisive leadership of Elizabeth, presented a campaign based on the fear
of terrorism.
Both Trump and Deutsch challenged the
wisdom of a campaign designed to scare New Yorkers. Trump fired Elizabeth on
the spot, choosing not to waste time with his traditional routine of
allowing the project manager to pick other candidates to face potential
firing in his boardroom.
This week, picking the loser was a no-brainer for Trump and the audience. We can all agree on this one. Andy may
be a freshman player, but he has displayed his talent, skill, and a firm
grasp of the fundamentals of effective leadership in this episode.
Although his age has made him a target
with his competition, don't count him out yet. He now has immunity for the
next episode and has successfully avoided being fired by Trump several
times. Trump seems to like him and though he may be 23, remember, the point
of this competition is to hire an apprentice. Typically, apprentices are
young.
|
How to Lead with Passion
"Leaders who are passionate about their vision can generate enthusiasm
and excitement among their employees and colleagues and motivate them to
achieve success,. But how to craft the messages and deliver them is
critical to getting buy-in from the rest of the organization."
-
Believe in your ideas with enthusiasm. If you have conviction
about your ideas, plans, projects or direction it will be reflected in
your voice, your words and your actions. Your passion will be apparent
and will influence others.
-
Build your case. Make your points for your ideas in both a
rational and emotional manner. The intensity of your feelings, combined
with facts and reason, will elicit support.
-
Be assertive. Assertive leaders gain respect because they
express themselves in an honest, straightforward manner. By speaking in
an assertive style, you can make your point and achieve your
goals without putting down or alienating other members of the team.
-
Be positive. Your delivery is as important as your words. The
tone and pitch of your words are an important part of your
communications. Listen to yourself to determine if you sound committed
to your idea. Your passion will be contagious.
-
Be responsive. Ask what it is about your idea that others
like best or least. Be a complete listener, one who leans into the
conversation and shows complete attention. Ask follow-up questions. They
will offer insights into their thinking. Your responses then can be
directed to their specific concerns.
-
Show confidence. Your physical posture says as much about
your commitment to an idea or belief, and your willingness to uphold it,
as do the words and tone of your voice. Non-verbal communication conveys
more than 90 percent of any message. Keep your head up and maintain eye
contact.
-
Be persistent. Stay the course. You may need to restate your
rationale and continue to demonstrate your intense feelings and
enthusiasm over time to secure full support from others. Remain focused
on the overall objective.
-
Accept responsibility.
If your approach fails, be the first to admit it. Others will respect
you for being forthright. Then review the situation, determine what went
wrong and learn how to do it better next time
PASS
-
Leadership with vision, passion,
emotional intelligence and backbone. Andy
gets my vote as the strongest candidate and leader this week. The
episode began with Andy returning from the boardroom only to overhear
his teammates predicting that he would be the next fired. He said he
"felt like the kid who never gets picked to play dodgeball on the
team." We all know from football and other sports that underdogs often
emerge victorious due to their great resolve and determination to win
despite the odds. Andy overcame his team's lack of confidence in his
abilities and led his team to victory. No easy task. How did he do it?
He led with vision, passion, emotional intelligence and backbone.
Andy began with a clear vision based
soundly on the expectations set by the customer. He led with passion
for his own creative idea, and passion breeds courage in a leader.
Even in the face of challenge by his
team members, he demonstrated clear authority, influence and
confidence that inspired his team to rally behind his vision.
Andy again displayed emotional
intelligence.
While under great stress and with
little time to shoot a commercial because of bad weather, Andy
remained calm and composed. This ability to remain calm under stress
is critical for leaders. Followers need leaders to provide order and
protection. Leaders who allow themselves to be "emotionally hijacked"
(a phrase coined by Daniel Goleman, author of "Primal Leadership:
Realizing the Power of Emotional Intelligence") while under stress are
doomed. Emotional hijacking occurs when our limbic, or emotional,
areas of the brain overtake the neocortex, or the thinking brain.
Having a leader lose their composure and control can be devastating to
a team. Leaders must be mindful of the impact of their emotions
on the team and master strategies to maintain and demonstrate
composure under stress. Andy proved he could lead a team, even through
a storm. He also demonstrated that leaders can compromise
without giving up control. He was able to maintain a precarious
balance of backbone and compromise. He allowed Kelly to give the main
pitch but insisted on doing the introduction himself. He demonstrated
maturity by not caving in to another strong leader, but was willing to
compromise as a strategy to maintain his leadership.
-
Give your customers what they ask
for. Mosaic won this task because they
listened to their customer. Their campaign capitalized on the emotion
and heart theme that Deutsch clearly wanted. This counts as a penalty
flag for Apex who instead, delivered a fear-based campaign.
Companies who don't listen to their customers will fail. This is not
complex, but, surprisingly, many companies fail to master this simple
business formula.
FAIL
-
Leadership is influence.
A leadership proverb: "He who thinketh he leadeth
and hath no one following him is only taking a walk." This sums up
Elizabeth who was a weak, indecisive leader. She failed to influence
her team to the point that they were inspired to mutiny. Successful
leadership is about the ability to influence. Just because you have
the position of authority does not mean that you are a leader. A
leader is nothing without followers. The good news is that influence
is a skill that can be developed through coaching, training and
experience.
-
Where's the vision?
Elizabeth's failed to communicate a clear vision and direction with
conviction and passion. This was unfortunate for Apex because even
though she was opposed to her team's military theme idea (the idea
that lost them the game), she was never able to lead her team to
clearly identify an alternative compelling vision. She continually
flipped back and forth between ideas which drove her sole ally, Kevin,
to finally declare: "Our project manager sucks." Elizabeth never led
an effective team process to identify a winning campaign strategy. She
was correct that the terrorism theme was not a winning strategy. Where
she failed was in her inability to convince her team and lead them
through a process of identifying a winning campaign idea. Her
direction was wishy-washy, which inspired open rebellion.
-
One dysfunctional team member can
turn a team in the wrong direction.
Raj displayed several dysfunctional team behaviors, including clowning
around and bullying Elizabeth into submitting to his military idea --
an idea that resulted in the team's loss. Instead of holding her own
structure, vision and order in meetings, Elizabeth caved to Raj's
unruly behavior. It is not uncommon in workplace teams to have
individuals forcefully ramrod their ideas on the group. How do
you deal with someone whose behavior disrupts the team? High
performing teams adopt agreed upon group norms or rules to help
control unruly team member behavior. Effective leaders also use
intervention techniques to alter disruptive patterns. For example,
Elizabeth might have tried this approach: "Raj, I notice that you
are yelling out your ideas and cutting others off. This behavior is
stifling our creative process. I am going to lead a brainstorming
process to come up with alternative ideas. Please hold your thoughts
until we have had a chance to hear and consider other ideas."
Elizabeth then could have given each team member an opportunity to
vote on the ideas that best met the criteria of the customer or she
could have announced that as the leader, she was going to make the
decision and assume responsibility for the consequences.
MAUREEN MORIARTY
SPECIAL TO THE SEATTLE POST-INTELLIGENCER
|
|
|